Work in Progress

Guilford Courthouse

Posted by John Simmons on 24 Mar 2025, 16:52

The recent release of Hat's very nice set of AWI American infantry inspired us to try another American Revolution game, in order to get some of these new figures into action on a table. We decided on Guilford Courthouse, which was one of the largest and most consequential battles in the war's Southern theater. Combined with Cowpens (which we have gamed before), Guilford Courthouse left Cornwallis too weak to continue campaigning in the interior. He was forced to retire to the coast, then into Virginia, finally falling into the trap at Yorktown.

I've been working on the table. I always begin with roads and watercourses, but in this case there is little of that to do. The North Carolina backcountry was mostly forest. One main road, the New Garden Road, ran through the middle of the field, meandering vaguely north as it went east. The only other road of consequence was the smaller Reedy Fork Road, which branched off to the north at the site of the Courthouse. Greene's army eventually retreated along this road in the actual battle. The field was crossed by two creeks running north to south -- Little Horsepen Cr. at the western edge and Hunting Cr. near the Courthouse. Neither creek was deep enough to affect the battle. They're on my table purely for decoration.

Image

Image

Much of Guilford Courthouse was fought in woods, a fact that helped the American army. But it also makes the field harder to model, given that the battle was fought in mid-March, when all of the hardwoods would have been bare of leaves. There were plenty of pines in the area, of course, but I've had to scrounge a bit to fill the table with bare trees and pines. The fields that had been cleared by local farmers also played a large role. The fields of Hoskins' farm, on the west, were the site of the first real engagement. Those further east, and in particular the area called by some "the vale", were important later in the battle. One participant in the battle noted that these muddy fields were "wrinkled". This gave me the idea of trying to represent them with suitably wrinkled, painted cloth. The results, I fear, were probably not worth the effort required.

Image

Image

Image

Image

Image

Image

Three small hills figured in the battle. One was heavily wooded and on the southern edge of the field.

Image

The other hills were on the northern edge and created between them the low "vale". Greene positioned his regulars in his third line of defense on the hill east of the "vale".

Image

Image

There were a few structures on the battlefield. But as it turns out, we know almost nothing about how they appeared. At the west edge was Hoskins' house and farmstead, roughly where the British right wing's advance began. A log house claimed to be the original Hoskins House still stands (about two hours south of where I live). In fact, the house there was built several decades later, though it probably resembles the one that stood there in 1781. Here's my version of that farmstead (Hoskins is hurrying to get his animals inside, before they become breakfast for a famished British army):

Image

Image

Image

Image

Image

Image

Then there is the actual Guilford Courthouse. It has been modelled before (by the old Architectural Heritage company), along with the Hoskins House and kitchen. But it is important to note that those models were based purely on conjecture, using descriptions of similar structures that stood in the Carolinas at that time. No contemporary drawing or description exists of either the Courthouse or the original Hoskins House. All we really know about the Courthouse (from its excavated foundations) is the rough footprint of the building, that it had at least one chimney, and that it had a front porch. While the eponymous Courthouse was probably a one or one-and-a-half story affair -- since relatively few two-story structures existed in the backcountry -- I've portrayed it as two-story (just for appearance), simply adding a front porch to an existing model in my collection. There were a few other structures on the battlefield that are shown on maps drawn by participants in the fight. But they are neither named nor described. A stone jail near the Courthouse is mentioned in one account, so I added that next to my Courthouse. And I've stuck a couple of suitable-looking buildings in the spots noted on the maps:

Image

Image

Image

Image

Image

Finally, here are a few views of (most of) the largely-completed field. First, looking east to west:

Image

Image

Image

And west to east:

Image

Image

Image

A few shots looking across the north-south axis:

Image

Image

Image

Now it's time to get to work assembling the armies.
John Simmons  United States of America
 
Posts: 70
Member since:
17 Apr 2020, 14:12


Posted by Iceman1964 on 24 Mar 2025, 19:24

Fascinating description John, it make us understand how work is behind a wargame !
User avatar
Iceman1964  Italy
 
Posts: 341
Member since:
26 Dec 2020, 17:43

Posted by Kekso on 25 Mar 2025, 09:35

Nice WIP. Thanks for the photos.
User avatar
Kekso  Croatia

Moderator Moderator
Supporting Member (Bronze) Supporting Member (Bronze)
 
Posts: 6911
Member since:
19 Oct 2011, 18:32

Posted by PaulRPetri on 25 Mar 2025, 16:52

Holy crap what a war-game set up!!! I have gamed on some excellent war-game tables in my 62 years of life but yours is right there at the top of the list!!

I also bought some of the new Hat AWI Americans and have taken the plunge into the AWI for some gaming.
PaulRPetri  United States of America
 
Posts: 755
Member since:
02 Apr 2019, 00:59

Posted by Ochoin on 26 Mar 2025, 04:20

Model Railway realism. I'm also impressed by the level of research.

It's work like this that puts the "historical" in Historical Wargaming.

donald
User avatar
Ochoin  Scotland
 
Posts: 2570
Member since:
16 Jan 2010, 04:00

Posted by C M Dodson on 26 Mar 2025, 11:21

Another masterpiece of visual wargaming in process.

Excellent work John as always.

The action I believe was in March and hence the winter landscape. It’s great.

Watch out for some of trees, they have gone wobbly on you!

Best wishes,

Chris
C M Dodson  United Kingdom
 
Posts: 2786
Member since:
01 May 2015, 18:48

Help keep the forum online!
or become a supporting member

Posted by Santi Pérez on 27 Mar 2025, 17:11

It's very interesting to see the development of the wargame scenary from the beginning until it's finished with only the armies missing for the clash. Great work, John! :thumbup:

Santi.
User avatar
Santi Pérez  Spain
 
Posts: 2297
Member since:
28 Aug 2016, 19:42

Posted by Rich W on 29 Mar 2025, 00:59

I’m sure this is going to be great once you them figures on the table!
Rich W  United Kingdom
 
Posts: 1408
Member since:
05 Feb 2018, 23:40

Posted by sberry on 31 Mar 2025, 08:12

Rich W wrote:I’m sure this is going to be great once you them figures on the table!

I think it looks already splendid without any figures yet, but I'm waiting for pics with the figures too!
User avatar
sberry  Germany
 
Posts: 1050
Member since:
12 Mar 2010, 20:37

Posted by John Simmons on 14 Apr 2025, 16:37

Thanks to all for your encouraging comments. While I continue to fiddle with the table (and with getting my trees less wobbly), I've been working on the flags for the game. In our rules (as in many others), flags are important because they mark the Command stands. On a cluttered field like Guilford Courthouse, the flags will help keep up the pace of play.

So ... AWI flags. That seems to be a subject about which not many people know very much. Perhaps some of you Forum readers can help me out here. I start with the British side, which is a lot easier. There are several contemporary accounts of the battle that mention all of the fluttering British colours displayed during their attack. Of Cornwallis' troops, the 33rd and 23rd (Fusilier) Foot regiments are straightforward, as both had their full complement of colours. The Hessians -- Von Bose's (Formerly Von Trumbach's) regiment -- are a bit less so. They almost certainly carried their one white Leibfahne, But nobody seems sure how many of the company colours the Hessian regiments in America carried. I've given them just one for this battle (the figures, here and below, are mostly metal from various manufacturers, all painted in my usual un-subtle, ham-fisted style):

Image

Because of Tarleton's disaster at Cowpens, Cornwallis was short on cavalry at Guilford Courthouse, having only some of the British Legion dragoons (who carried this banner):

Image

Things are trickier with the Highlanders and the Guards. The Foot Guards battalions sent to America were drawn from all three of the Guards regiments, so their King's Colours almost certainly remained in England. They may have carried no flags at all. I've given each of Cornwallis' Guards battalions one company colour to carry (which, in the case of the Guards' reversed colours, would have been a Union Jack, with appropriate company designations on it):

Image

I've been unable to discover whether the two battalions of the 71st (Fraser's) Highlanders that were raised for the war in America each carried their own full complement of colours. The First Battalion, we know, was effectively wiped out at Cowpens. But I can find nothing about whether their colours were saved, destroyed, or captured. I've guessed and given the small Second Battalion of the 71st just a single regimental flag to carry at Guilford Courthouse:

Image

Now for the Americans. As far as I know, there are no accounts of which -- if any -- flags were carried by the American forces at Guilford Courthouse. So everything I've done here is just (vaguely educated) guesswork. There is one American flag that is usually associated with this battle. Indeed, it's often called the Guilford Courthouse flag". Here it is (with some of the new Hat figures):

Image

There are three theories about this flag: that it was flown atop the Courthouse during the fight; that it was carried by the North Carolina militia; or that it was actually a flag from the War of 1812. I've given it to the N.C. militia, along with a widely popular "Liberty" flag (since there were two "brigades" -- mobs? -- of N.C. militia, they need two flags for our game's Command purposes):

Image

There were also present at the fight two brigades of Virginia militia. I've given each one of the red-white striped flags that were popular in Virginia:

Image

The Continental regiments in Greene's army were, I think, more likely to have actually carried flags. But I can find no record of which flags they carried (and since all were "composite" regiments, constructed from the remains of other units, my guesses here are even less reliable). We know that one of the Gostelowe standards is associated with a different Maryland regiment, so I've given Greene's two Maryland regiments one of those, along with one of the newly-popular national flags:

Image

The two regiments of Virginia Continentals both get red flags, of the sorts used by other Virginia units:

Image

Greene had two units of cavalry at his disposal: William Washington's Continentals (a mix from the 1st and 3rd Dragoons) and the horse troops in "Light Horse Harry" Lee's Legion. I've' given Washington's dragoons the flag of the 1st regiment. An existing flag from Lee's Legion has the 'horsehead' symbol on a white field. But there is specific mention of the Legion carrying a red flag at Guilford Courthouse, so I've given them that:

Image

Image

I'm back now to tinkering with the field and trying to incorporate more of Hat's plastics into my (not-very-attractive) metal AWI armies.
John Simmons  United States of America
 
Posts: 70
Member since:
17 Apr 2020, 14:12

Posted by C M Dodson on 14 Apr 2025, 17:20

Brilliant stuff as always.

I love your various flags and the thought that has gone into them.

I do not know much about this period but I do know an Airfix Washington’s Army officer when I see one.

A stalwart item bringing back many memories.

Keep it up, it’s excellent work.

Best wishes,

Chris
C M Dodson  United Kingdom
 
Posts: 2786
Member since:
01 May 2015, 18:48

Posted by Iceman1964 on 14 Apr 2025, 18:43

An incredible amount of research and passion for this "hunt for the right flag" !
best compliments John
User avatar
Iceman1964  Italy
 
Posts: 341
Member since:
26 Dec 2020, 17:43

Posted by PaulRPetri on 15 Apr 2025, 02:05

John I appreciate your Ham Fisted painting style!!! I have to say I only recognized a few figures which are plastic 1/72. Are there some old Garrison and Minifig metals in your command groups?
Nice work!!
PaulRPetri  United States of America
 
Posts: 755
Member since:
02 Apr 2019, 00:59


Return to Work in Progress